On Second Thought: Steelers-Bengals, Week 8

via newmediarockstars DeAngelo Williams, holding up his end, although not in this game…

by Ivan Cole

We were without Homer J today, who is in the Canadian Rockies doing some serious bucket list stuff. I was inclined to consider him lucky even though he was missing what promised to be a big and exciting game. Now I think he was also lucky to have missed this little tragedy.

This was not to say that we suffered from an attendance standpoint. PaVaSteelers was present, and Hombre de Acero, who provides us with “5 Smoldering Questions,” was making one of his infrequent visits back home from Buenos Aires, Argentina. So, with those two and my brother I suffered in good company.

The first drive

All signs pointed to a pleasant afternoon on the Steelers first offensive drive of the game. Ben was showing some rust, but not enough to hamper the team’s march down the field. There was little nervousness until it was first and goal inside of the ten. A CBS graphic pointed out that the Steelers led the NFL in games where they had failed to score a touchdown on its first offensive possession (15). I didn’t have that information at my fingertips, but even without it there was an intuitive concern that the good feelings would be soured and there would be a note of danger if Pittsburgh was forced to settle for three points.

So it was as much relief as joy when Antonio Brown caught that slant pass from Ben that gave the Steelers a lead that would hold up for most of the rest of the game. AB’s method of celebration was different in tone from what you might consider normal for him, and drew a lot of amused reactions. He got on his knees and raised his arms Heavens-ward in apparent thanksgiving.

Greg, the owner of Wiener’s Circle where we were gathered, was somewhat relieved. A Navy Vet and decidedly old school concerning player behavior, he has this thing about player celebrations, particularly when they happen in relation to somewhat mundane occurrences such as making a catch. When it was pointed out that some players may actually realize something of a financial windfall when they accomplish these things his position softened a little, but just a little.

For many of the rest of us we concluded that he was praying to God (or to Ben as the case may be) that he had been delivered from the purgatory of trying to make a decent living with Pittsburgh’s backup quarterbacks. As it was Ben got pretty much everyone involved in the drive with the exceptions of Heath and Markus Wheaton. The situation with Heath would be rectified in spades later in the game.

Cincinnati’s response

The Bengals willed their way down the field in their first offensive possession and settled for a field goal. At this point in the proceedings it appeared that it was absolutely essential that Cincy come away with points every time they touched the ball. Given the reputation of the Bengal offense and the fact that Ben was back and had available all his key offensive weapons, particularly Brown, Bell, Bryant and all the others, you could be forgiven for believing that the outcome could more closely resemble the Giants/Saints game where both teams combined for over 100 points of offense.

But let’s be clear about a few things. In spite of their, now, 7-0 record, the Bengal offense is far from frightening. Or maybe it’s just a matter of giving props to the Steelers defense. They give ground, but you are rarely left with the impression that they concede control. The fact is that one of the bottom line and tragic issues that has been exposed as the Steelers fall to .500 is that the defense has played well enough for Pittsburgh to have the undefeated record. And this in spite of the fact that they have been as personnel challenged as the offense, while Cincy has been remarkably healthy through this point of the season. More about this angle later.

Now, if you are subject to depression or crying jags, you might want to skip down a few paragraphs.

Burfict’s revenge

The Steelers’ offense sputtered a little for the remainder of the 1st quarter, but one thing was clear as we watched them work; that Le’Veon Bell was at the top of food chain here. Yes, they stopped him from time to time, but they weren’t going to stop him all the time. And despite Ben and AB and Martavis and Heath and DeAngelo, it was clear that Bell was the guy.

I saw it first.

Everyone else was celebrating the nine yard gain on the pass play, but I saw the body language as he fell out of bounds. And then I saw him clutch his knee. And the joy was gone.

Everything was different after that. Someone said the season was over and that was a hard sentiment to argue against. I was ping ponging between depression and anger. Anger because what are the chances of Bell suffering the same injury against the same team as just being ‘part of the game’? I fully acknowledge that I was looking for someone to scapegoat and blame for depriving Steelers Nation of its joy. Vontaze Burfict, most likely still smarting from the emasculation he suffered at the hands of Willie Colon, seemed a perfect target.

I wasn’t alone. PaVa, who monitors the game thread at Behind The Steel Curtain, reported that the folks there were on “suicide watch”. Sandwiched between the expressions of resignation and despair were calls for Jihad. And you would have dismissed it as just disgruntled fan talk, but apparently some on the Steelers defense were thinking along the same lines.

As we watched shots of Bell being examined on a table in a manner reminiscent of the last time these two teams met in December 2014, the intensity on the field seemed to go up significantly. Bengals receivers seemed to be getting the worst of it, with Mike Mitchell bringing realistic meaning to the term ‘cutting an opponent in two’. He also picked up a penalty for taunting that drew more understanding from those assembled than might ordinarily be the case.

Hombre opined that player availability (injuries plus suspensions) now appeared to be the defining issue of this season. Don’t expect Tomlin or anyone else in an official capacity with the team to acknowledge this. In fact, expect them to deny it vehemently. But the facts don’t lie.

The closest thing to Pittsburgh being able to put its full complement of players on the field (and that’s excluding Maurkice Pouncey and Kelvin Beachum, aka “All Pro Center” and “starting Left Tackle) was for one quarter of one game. And even then that is ignoring Ben’s early return from injury. The full complement will not be seen this year. Nor is it confined to the offensive side of the ball. What is most impressive about the defense is that they have played at a high level with key pieces (the Allens, Tuitt, McCullers, Shazier, Jones) missing for various periods. And, of course there were the placekickers.

Please spare us all the standard is the standard mantra.

Ben Roethlisberger

This brings us to the other piece of unfortunate business for this afternoon. The defense played their collective behinds off today, especially in the second half, and deserved a better level of support from their offensive brethren.

Many of us have been trying hard to hate on Antwon Blake, and this seemed the perfect opportunity. He appeared over his head in his match up with A J Green, but he continues to tackle like a maniac and his interception at the goal line would have been the big story of a Steelers win, had there been a Steelers win. Cam Heyward’s block of an attempted field goal, Mitchell and Harrison and Shazier and Cockrell, just to name a few. Time and again they turned away the supposedly high octane Bengals offense. Sixteen points surrendered (only six until the last couple minutes of the game) should, no, must translate into a winning effort. Only it didn’t.

Granted, Cincinnati has a defense too. But not one good enough to hold this offense to ten points on their own steam. Miller, Bell, while he was around and DeAngelo Williams held up their end for the most part. Both AB and Bryant dropped passes that any professional receiver should have caught. But special mention has to be made about Ben who at times seemed to have regressed to the Bruce Arians era. His three interceptions broke this team’s back, to put it simply.

I came away sad for a defense that deserved better. Sad for Ben whose fears came to fruition. But especially sad for all fans of pro football who will be deprived of the brilliance of Le’Veon Bell.

Looking for humor? In the game’s final moments I joked that someone in Steeler Nation was going to call for the return of Landry Jones. PaVa reported that several already had. That’s awfully close to hitting bottom, folks.


  • BTSC is all about scraping the bottom these days.

    I was prepared for the Steelers to lose this game due to a belief that the Bengals are legit and Big Ben would be rusty. The loss of Bell was devastating because it took away BR’s new favorite comfort blankie. The chemistry between Ben and the WRs was clearly affected by his absence, understandably so. Heath’s stat line is enough proof of that. Big Ben returned to his original safety comfort blankie.

    The team is 4-4. A 6-2 second half is still playoff worthy, imo. Though the Raiders are showing they are going to be a player in that race too.

    Still… the season feels snakebit. I’m almost wondering if it is worth letting Big Ben sit until he’s fully healed. A gimpy Ben isn’t a useful Ben.


  • Snake bit is the term that came to mind for me too when I saw Bell’s injury. Let’s hope Ben can shake off the rust before the Raiders cone to town. As much as I hate to say it this early, the raiders game is shaping up as a must win for the playoffs.


  • cold_old_steelers_fan

    I could have sworn Cody Wallace had been listed as probable (illness) before the game. Does anyone know what illness he had?

    Ben had a rough outing. I wonder how much was Ben trying to do too much too soon.


    • Never heard anything further than “Illness.”
      I think MOST of Ben’s rough outing could be put down to trying to do too much too soon, but in which sense? Was he healed enough to come back? Probably not, but I’m guessing guys are almost never “healed enough to come back.” Was he trying to force things that weren’t there as he got increasingly banged up and nervous? Probably. I’m guessing it had a lot to do with Bell going down and figuring it was all on him.


  • cold_old_steelers_fan

    Bell has been put on IR. Isaiah Pead signed to fill roster spot.


  • Love the A\B purgatory quote. If you ask him he would probably say he was in receiver hell. Ha Ha. Speaking of God. God bless Levon Bell. Bell sets a standard that no current NFL RB can meet.
    Penalty’s/Ref’s; Foster had his name called on a key holding penalty that took away a first down at the 8 yard line for the Steelers and we settled for 3 on that drive. 2 BIG 15 yarders! One ticky tacky one against Mitchell and one taking your helmet off…..sigh. A CLEAR first down that needed a red flag intervention to get overturned even though the Ref was right on top the play. After a “ref huddle a “no restriction” on the PI call in the end zone. Really? Never heard of that one before and he seen less get called. OK I am done whining about uncontrollable events.
    One man to beat; If Bernard does not tackle Blake on his INT return he takes it about 103 yards to the house.
    Wonder how Ben’s knee is holding up? If he can move next week like he did this week then look for a big game from him and the receivers(30+ points) Go ahead call me a homer I don’t mind.
    It’s a fine line between winning and losing and yes the standard is the standard in all phases of the game. This 4-4 team is still pretty damn good and still ascending. Elpalito mentioned 10-6 will most likely get them in and I agree. Make it or not I will definitely enjoy the ride.


  • Agreeing with the BTSC bottom dwelling comment, it gets a bit whiny at times. Still, glad that Ben owned up to this one being on his shoulders. With all that’s gone on this year, Pittsburgh is still 4-4 and playoffs are still in the realm… this one was a tough loss, but we’re not dead yet…


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s